Travel to Spain and Portugal for 6 months

They can laugh all they want , it’s still a dent in the Spanish economy.
People will soon find other places to spend their money.
It's the whole of Schengen that the 90/180 applies.....what percentage of Brits come to Schengen for more than 90 days....and what percentage of Brits come to Schengen for one.two or three week holidays in the summer..
Furthermore it's only Brits that could be physically restricted...all other nationals can still travel , and spend as they wish...
..
 
Last edited:
Just out of interest, if you had a 90 day limit, less travelling time, which months would you choose?
Personally I would do Jan, Feb, and a bit of March.
Phil
Phil

We would do what we usually did before Brexit and Covid. March April and May for some early sunshine and September October and November for some late sunshine. And we can still do that after Brexit, once Europe opens up again that is.
 
It's the whole of Schengen that the 90/180 applies.....what percentage of Brits come to Schengen for more than 90 days....and what percentage of Brits come to Schengen for one.two or three week holidays in the summer..
Furthermore it's only Brits that could be physically restricted...all other nationals can still travel , and spend as they wish...
..
Get a Frenchman to spend🤣🤣 pull the other one,,BUSBY.
 
And you've been here long enough to know there are rules about being smart arse. 😀 It was a genuine question that didn't need your injection of remainer/leaver/referendum rubbish. Please desist. Thanks

Hmmm

I think JJ is actually highlighting the irony of Brexit

We voted to separate ourselves from Europe, but at the same time we still love going there whenever we want and would like to stay for as long as we want

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
Hmmm

I think JJ is actually highlighting the irony of Brexit

We voted to separate ourselves from Europe, but at the same time we still love going there whenever we want and would like to stay for as long as we want

Hmmm indeed.

We did vote. It was 4 years ago. And posts like that just keep the argument going. JJ can take the irony somewhere else. It just causes needless arguments here.
 
Last May I suggested some figures, showing that restricting motorhomers to 90 days MIGHT reduce Spain's economy by €30M pa (compared to their GDP of €95 000 000M). [ie 0.000032%]
Those figures RELY on 10 000Brits EACH spending €100 per day.

I don't know 10 000 British motorhomers who spend 90 days in Spain, let alone more than 90 days.
I don't know any British motorhomers who spend €100 per day in Spain, every day for 4 months.

So please get realistic: the size of the dent is minuscule based on my figures.
If someone can offer more accurate figures then please supply them so that we can see how important we are.

Gordon
Lets imagine that 10 000 Brit MHs normally go to Spain for the winter and spend €100 per day [is this stretching the imagination?]. That amounts to €1M per day.

Say they normally stay for 4 months = 120 days.
WHEN restricted to 90 days, Spain loses €30M.
In 2019 Spain's GDP was approx $1.4trillion. [approx €95 000 000M]

WHO thinks that amount will be significant, even given the loss to the economy caused by Covid-19?
For those who do, will it be sufficiently significant to go against every other Schengen country (except perhaps Portugal) and allow Brits to stay longer than every other third-country resident?

Reality needs to make an appearance at some point! :rolleyes:

Gordon
Haha, you should work for a government agency with your back of a fag packet, wildly inaccurate guesstimate .
 
Haha, you should work for a government agency with your back of a fag packet, wildly inaccurate guesstimate .

How do you know that it is wildly inaccurate? :oops:

I'm fairly sure that there are more than 100 but not as many as 100 000: do you agree?
Feel free to put any number you want into the calculation.

I suspect most will pay more than €10 per day: two of us averaged €20 (inc fuel & food) in 2018 but we spent most nights on aires. I don't imagine that very many spend €100 per day but perhaps some do.

BUT there is this belief that our value to the Spanish economy is significant and they will bend their rules in order to allow us to stay over 90 days. So I stuck in what I considered to be generous figures and got the numbers which I quoted. ie 0.000032% of GDP.
Last year I was criticised for being overly generous: clearly if we spend less than I have suggested then we have an even smaller effect!
Hopefully realism will dawn at some point. ;)

Gordon
 
Whatever the effect on a national level will be, on a local level Brexit must have some effect, if Brits who previously spent five or even six months in Spain/Portugal can now only do three then there must be some effect to the local economy, remember it is in their low season, perhaps some of that business will be taken up by people from other EU countries but not all of it will be. From my own experience, my sister and her husband had a small hotel in a ski resort, it was full throughout the ski season but once it was over there was a period when there were so few bookings that it was not worth opening until summer comes along and you get some walkers and climbers staying, over the course of a year they were lucky to break even and the hotel is now a block of flats. For some of these local businesses in Spain/Portugal there will be a fine line between profit and loss and it would be in their interest if their Governments developed a visa solution that would facilitate non working third country nationals to stay for longer periods providing they have appropriate medical insurance and the means to maintain themselves. Just my opinion.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
Last edited:
From Emmit Towers, I have no problem with the 90 day rule per se.
It's the 180 that follows it. (I know it's 90/180)
We have spent hours trying to work out our plans because of that rule.
I appreciate that there might? be some citizens of the UK that would abuse the opportunity to come and go with a limit of 90 days per visit but, in these days of electronic passports, the EU could simply convey to the mickey taker that they were, for a period, persona non gratia.
What, (apart from the rules) would be so wrong with say, Jan, Feb, March in Spain and then June in France.
As said, nothing apart from "The rules"
 
Last edited:
The 90/180 rule was not made up by the EU to cover Brexit. It was an existing rule that they have had for a long time dealing with visitors who were not citizens of an EU country. That is what we became on Brexit, like it or not. I do not know whether the UK government asked them to change it or not during negotiations, but that is irrelevant because the fact is that it wasn't changed to make an exception for us.

We all have to live with it unless and until the EU decides to change it. At the end of the day the politicians the UK elect have no direct say in that change.

I think once things settle down we may seem some changes. But, as I understand it, the popularity of motorhomes has increased in the rest of Europe as it has done here because of Covid. That may mean that Southern Europe will not miss its influx of long staying motorhoming Brits as much as people think they will.

After all this rule is not going effect the huge influx of Brits who fly to Spain for their 2 or 3 week holidays..
 
How do you know that it is wildly inaccurate? :oops:

I'm fairly sure that there are more than 100 but not as many as 100 000: do you agree?
Feel free to put any number you want into the calculation.

I suspect most will pay more than €10 per day: two of us averaged €20 (inc fuel & food) in 2018 but we spent most nights on aires. I don't imagine that very many spend €100 per day but perhaps some do.

BUT there is this belief that our value to the Spanish economy is significant and they will bend their rules in order to allow us to stay over 90 days. So I stuck in what I considered to be generous figures and got the numbers which I quoted. ie 0.000032% of GDP.
Last year I was criticised for being overly generous: clearly if we spend less than I have suggested then we have an even smaller effect!
Hopefully realism will dawn at some point. ;)

Gordon
Let’s be really accurate, my guess is 11 or more , but less than 999990.
Sorry for the sarcasm.
It’s guesswork but please carry on.
 
From Emmit Towers, I have no problem with the 90 day rule per se.
It's the 180 that follows it. (I know it's 90/180)
We have spent hours trying to work out our plans because of that rule.
I appreciate that there might? be some citizens of the UK that would abuse the opportunity to come and go with a limit of 90 days per visit but, in these days of electronic passports, the EU could simply convey to the mickey taker that they were, for a period, persona non gratia.
What, (apart from the rules) would be so wrong with say, Jan, Feb, March in Spain and then June in France.
As said, nothing apart from "The rules"
Perhaps July...

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
From Emmit Towers, I have no problem with the 90 day rule per se.
It's the 180 that follows it. (I know it's 90/180)
We have spent hours trying to work out our plans because of that rule.
I appreciate that there might? be some citizens of the UK that would abuse the opportunity to come and go with a limit of 90 days per visit but, in these days of electronic passports, the EU could simply convey to the mickey taker that they were, for a period, persona non gratia.
What, (apart from the rules) would be so wrong with say, Jan, Feb, March in Spain and then June in France.
As said, nothing apart from "The rules"
Enter your planned dates and previous stays in the Schengen calculator and it generates the 90 and 180 days automatically. If you travel jointly with an EU national [Irish Passport?], then ignore any stays when you are both together because they don't count for the purposes of the 90 and 180 days calulation.

Days Stay in EU with EU Passport Holder Partner

Clear as mud!

Steve
 
When things return to a little normality we will probably spend Jan. Feb. and March in Spain as normal .
Because of the 90/180 law we will probably only use Schengen countries briefly in transit the rest of the year.
If we enjoy the ‘new to us ‘destinations we may well not bother with Spain , Italy, France etc in the future.
Now I realise some people reckon the money my wife and I spend whilst travelling abroad is a drop In the ocean, but I reckon it amounts to a job lost for one of our EU friends.
 
The Joint Travel with EU Passport Holder Regs [Page 17 Sec 2.1.2] are dated October are dated 8th October 2019, quite a while before the Final EU/UK Agreement was made, and others have posted that the wording is clumsy. May need to be tidied up if/when the topic is revisited. There were articles doing the rounds in early Autumn about the day of arrival and departure counting as 2 days of your 90, even if it was 23:55 and 00:05 respectively, but the Schengen Stay Calculator does not appear to pick this up, so it might be wise to dock a day from you proposed exit date, rather than risk a stressful conversation with a Border Guard.

Steve
 
Apart from last year we have wintered in Spain for 6 months from 2008 and really enjoyed it especially in the the earlier years with the Camping Club rally’s at La Manga. We decided last year to reduce it to 3 months for various reasons and look forward to doing the same this year from January to March. There will be many people disappointed that 6 months is not currently an option and I can understand why but at the moment there does not appear to be a way around it apart from going to Morocco.
Turkey,,Fab country,, look at Tread the Globe on You Tube...Visited a couple of times but watching Tread the Globe who have been stuck there for a year now shows what a beautiful country and how friendly the people are and if your into history and ruins well it will blow your mind. BUSBY.
 
Enter your planned dates and previous stays in the Schengen calculator and it generates the 90 and 180 days automatically. If you travel jointly with an EU national [Irish Passport?], then ignore any stays when you are both together because they don't count for the purposes of the 90 and 180 days calulation.

Days Stay in EU with EU Passport Holder Partner

Clear as mud!

Steve
Thank you.
I did know about the various calendars
This one:https://www.schengenvisainfo.com/visa-calculator/
was fine until we changed the dates when online and it accepted the dates. However, had we 'believed' the dates we would have been in the doo-doo.

I then went onto;https://ec.europa.eu/assets/home/visa-calculator/calculator.htm?lang=en
and found it, whilst not as user friendly, accurate.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
Turkey,,Fab country,, look at Tread the Globe on You Tube...Visited a couple of times but watching Tread the Globe who have been stuck there for a year now shows what a beautiful country and how friendly the people are and if your into history and ruins well it will blow your mind. BUSBY.
Spent three years in Turkey. Fabulous country for sailing. Great sightseeing. Generous people. And, I would think, almost unlimited opportunities for wild camping.
 
2002-2005 was just the beginning of Erdogan regime and it was a lot different then than now. Still, I'd go again now because of the people, the scenery and the food. If I applied human rights as a test, I never visit anywhere including the UK!
There was never any intention to suggest that you do not visit Turkey! The more visitors, the better it will be observed.
My comment was just to address your apparently rose tinted view of the country.
Your "dig" at the UK is foolish and undeserved, and coming from someone from Mexico is hard to credit.
I will not post again on this topic (politics is probably not allowed)
BUT - Could you consider that with at least 15000 women murdered in Turkey since you were there , (2004)it might just be worth a mention?
With severe restrictions on the right to assembly in Turkey and the disproptionate reaction to mainly Kurdish assemblies by lesbian ,gay ,bisexual or transgender (LGBT) groups , frankly - your eyes must be in your arse!
Best take your rosy tinted glasses home with you.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
2002-2005 was just the beginning of Erdogan regime and it was a lot different then than now. Still, I'd go again now because of the people, the scenery and the food. If I applied human rights as a test, I never visit anywhere including the UK!
And your from Mexico :LOL::doh:
 
When things return to a little normality we will probably spend Jan. Feb. and March in Spain as normal .
Because of the 90/180 law we will probably only use Schengen countries briefly in transit the rest of the year.
If we enjoy the ‘new to us ‘destinations we may well not bother with Spain , Italy, France etc in the future.
Now I realise some people reckon the money my wife and I spend whilst travelling abroad is a drop In the ocean, but I reckon it amounts to a job lost for one of our EU friends.

Being someone that lives in Spain and rents an apartment out for holiday rental, the people that spend money are here for a week or two, working people when times precious normally with a young family 🙂 they are on holiday they spend money. 😁

Being a motorhomer since 2007 I can tell you that most motorhomers are a different breed, the ones that come long stay do not pay the premium prices for campsites in summer months, eat and drink out every day in restaurants when prices are high and so on. 😉

If you feel winter discount campsites, cheap motorhome stops or free camping along with menu del dia and euro bars is spending money, 🙂 I'm afraid your wrong. 😁
A lot of bars and restaurants don't even bother opening in the quite times, just like holiday rental is it really worth renting out in winter for €600 a month, when you can get more than that a week in low period. 🙄

When we stay here in summer we have to go somewhere cheaper, no way would we spend a fortune stopping on the coast in campsites or camperstops, you need more than a flexible friend to eat out without heading in land. 😁 Bob.
 
There was never any intention to suggest that you do not visit Turkey! The more visitors, the better it will be observed.
My comment was just to address your apparently rose tinted view of the country.
Your "dig" at the UK is foolish and undeserved, and coming from someone from Mexico is hard to credit.
I will not post again on this topic (politics is probably not allowed)
BUT - Could you consider that with at least 15000 women murdered in Turkey since you were there , (2004)it might just be worth a mention?
With severe restrictions on the right to assembly in Turkey and the disproptionate reaction to mainly Kurdish assemblies by lesbian ,gay ,bisexual or transgender (LGBT) groups , frankly - your eyes must be in your arse!
Best take your rosy tinted glasses home with you.
Nothing at all rose tinted about my view of Turkey or of Mexico for that matter. I understand all of the above and accept that there isn't a lot I can do about it. But, as I said, and all I said, is that it wouldn't stop me from visiting, nor will it stop me from living in Mexico along with a couple million other expats despite all of the human rights issues in this country. It didn't stop me from visiting South Africa, Egypt, Sudan, Eritrea Yemen or a host of other places where human rights are not necessarily a top priority. In my view, it's always better to engage than disengage with questionable regimes.
 
Being someone that lives in Spain and rents an apartment out for holiday rental, the people that spend money are here for a week or two, working people when times precious normally with a young family 🙂 they are on holiday they spend money. 😁

Being a motorhomer since 2007 I can tell you that most motorhomers are a different breed, the ones that come long stay do not pay the premium prices for campsites in summer months, eat and drink out every day in restaurants when prices are high and so on. 😉

If you feel winter discount campsites, cheap motorhome stops or free camping along with menu del dia and euro bars is spending money, 🙂 I'm afraid your wrong. 😁
A lot of bars and restaurants don't even bother opening in the quite times, just like holiday rental is it really worth renting out in winter for €600 a month, when you can get more than that a week in low period. 🙄

When we stay here in summer we have to go somewhere cheaper, no way would we spend a fortune stopping on the coast in campsites or camperstops, you need more than a flexible friend to eat out without heading in land. 😁 Bob.
But those sites and restaurants that stay open in the winter don't do it to provide a service ,,,they obviously make some money or they would not bother..When I was in haulage back load rates were terrible but every little helped, We snowbirds don't spend anywhere as much as those on their annual two week holiday but we do spend over a much longer period at a time when without us resorts and sites would be empty.. BUSBY
 
But those sites and restaurants that stay open in the winter don't do it to provide a service ,,,they obviously make some money or they would not bother..When I was in haulage back load rates were terrible but every little helped, We snowbirds don't spend anywhere as much as those on their annual two week holiday but we do spend over a much longer period at a time when without us resorts and sites would be empty.. BUSBY
In the past the sites that have been Open have been full, and the restaurants those that make the effort are providing a service and yes great for us, but often think what you charge you can't make any money and just cover the overheads it keeps the staff, family run don't bother they open when money can be made. 😁
But your only taking about English, and your only talking about the fact they can only spend 3 months instead of maybe 6, 🤔 it's not as if has that pitch is left empty for 3 months because your not there, you leave someone else comes and continue to do what you would have done. 😁 Snowbirds come in many nationalities. 😎

And Yes I know all about back load rates but they are only cr#p if you do them, for me they had to be on route and be On and Off the same day, we run trucks, first one a Volvo after the second time on a recovery truck that went, we bought our first Scania, sold our trailer and hired or pulled other people's far less hassle the next 3 Scania was 44t tag or mid lift last one went in 2005 when I lost my sight in one eye and retired. 🙂
Happy day's 😉 I think BUSBY. 🤔
😁 Bob.
Screenshot_20210321-182811_Photos.jpgScreenshot_20210321-194853_Photos.jpg

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 

Join us or log in to post a reply.

To join in you must be a member of MotorhomeFun

Join MotorhomeFun

Join us, it quick and easy!

Log in

Already a member? Log in here.

Latest journal entries

Back
Top