For the love of dogs, Alison Hammond? (2 Viewers)

[Odd job]

We watched the first episode with Alison and we were disappointed. I think she did a good job but it wasn't a good show. I wonder if the show was ever good or if it was just Paul who made it good

 

[Silver-Fox]

Suffered 30 secounds, that was enough for us.

 

[Littlewheels]

Suffered 30 secounds, that was enough for us.

We do this, it’s odd really as a programme starts that you are all ready for, a Drama,Documentary etc and within a matter of seconds you know it’s a non starter.

 

[Head Gardener]

Paul O'Grady was unique, glorious one-off, and I don't think there is anyone who could follow him on any programme. When he cuddled a lonely dog who needed some comfort you KNEW he meant it.

Ms Hammond is far too ebullient* and enthusiastic for my taste, and I cannot watch her - everything she does seems to be about HER reaction to it all, she's even ruined Bake Off.


(* my spell check wants to change that to embalmment )

 

[TerryL]

Was looking forward to the new show, but we were both disappointed. Don't really think Alison Hammond is right for the role of replacing Paul - not saying he can never be replaced but a far less "ebullient" (yep that's the right word) presenter would make a better job of it IMO.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Gina M]

The show is not the same without Paul. I watched the first one but not going to watch the rest. Paul really had a love of dogs and I miss that.

 

[JRT]

I agree, Hammond is a poor replacement, she clearly doesn't have the same affection for dogs that O'Grady did.

The show should have been allowed to quietly disappear.

 

[TerryL]

The show should have been allowed to quietly disappear.

Which would be a shame as Battersea needs as much help as it can get with the ever-increasing numbers of strays and hand-ins. Whilst it is supposed to be entertainment the show also brings the plight of countless lost and ailing dogs to the world.

 

[scotzsue]

Only ever saw bits of the show, but can't imagine anyone with a 'big' personality being right for the show, need someone who genuinely loves and has empathy for dogs,
I do watch the dog house and think most of those working there would do a much better job

 

[RobbyMClark]

The woman irritates me so will be missing a nice and gentle feelgood show.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[iandsm]

We watched the first episode with Alison and we were disappointed. I think she did a good job but it wasn't a good show. I wonder if the show was ever good or if it was just Paul who made it good

It was Paul who made it good. I’ve nothing against her but she is just an “out of the box” presenter who could be telling us all about her love of anything you care to mention

 

[iandsm]

Ex

Only ever saw bits of the show, but can't imagine anyone with a 'big' personality being right for the show, need someone who genuinely loves and has empathy for dogs,
I do watch the dog house and think most of those working there would do a much better job

Apart from the 5 year old receptionist.

 

[Gina M]

I love Alison, but not for this show. With Paul you just knew he cried for some of the dogs. I can't watch it anymore it depresses me. I love The Dog House as that is a feel good show.

 

[scotzsue]

Ex

Apart from the 5 year old receptionist.

I think she is ideal for the job, can imagine she grates on some, she manages to put everyone at their ease though and also loves the dogs. Can you imagine the show with your usual, non funster, doctor's receptionist in the post. Most folks would go elsewhere.
wish i had her energy, she always makes me smile.

 

[JRT]

I think she is ideal for the job, can imagine she grates on some, she manages to put everyone at their ease though and also loves the dogs. Can you imagine the show with your usual, non funster, doctor's receptionist in the post. Most folks would go elsewhere.
wish i had her energy, she always makes me smile.

Yes she is a bit irritating but she is ideal for the shelter and for the program actually.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[JRT]

Which would be a shame as Battersea needs as much help as it can get with the ever-increasing numbers of strays and hand-ins. Whilst it is supposed to be entertainment the show also brings the plight of countless lost and ailing dogs to the world.

That's a fair point, so maybe not let it disappear but do a complete 'rebrand' still based at Battersea and with a different presenter.

It just doesn't work in the same format without O'Grady doing it.

(It's a bit like trying to replace Dave Myers as one of the Hairy Bikers.)

 

[15edward]

I was told the receptionist is an actor not staff

 

[JRT]

I was told the receptionist is an actor not staff

A quick Google confirms this is indeed correct. She was hired specifically for the program.

She is called Elisha Duffy.

 

[Branston]

Which would be a shame as Battersea needs as much help as it can get with the ever-increasing numbers of strays and hand-ins. Whilst it is supposed to be entertainment the show also brings the plight of countless lost and ailing dogs to the world.

Hands up! I didn't watch the show because I had a gut feeling that it wouldn't be the same without Paul. Problem is that Battersea needs the attention of the public and donations. I am not qualified to put forward suggestions for another presenter but I hope they can eventually settle for someone of Paul's merit.

 

[jumartoo]

Sorry, but I've never taken to Alison. She may be liked by millions but not me.

Paul was "one in a million". He did a great job with the dogs and is, still, sadly missed.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[x17ken]

Hands up! I didn't watch the show because I had a gut feeling that it wouldn't be the same without Paul. Problem is that Battersea needs the attention of the public and donations. I am not qualified to put forward suggestions for another presenter but I hope they can eventually settle for someone of Paul's merit.

I agree and don't ever forget about the poor inmates. The presenter needs to show real empathy for their plight - which Paul did in bucket loads. He is massive loss to publicising the challenges that Battersea faces day in and day out.

 

[CazPaul]

Whoever took over was going to get compared and receive criticism

I think she has a lovely, happy, smiley personality and a great love of dogs.

 

[Nanniemate]

It's just not the same. But the world moves on

 

[WESTY66]

Sorry, but I've never taken to Alison. She may be liked by millions but not me.

Paul was "one in a million". He did a great job with the dogs and is, still, sadly missed.

Ditto

 

[Larrynwin]

Bake off and For the love of dogs two favourite programmes I will miss spoiled by choice of presenter imo .

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}

 

[Wee Bold Davy]

Paul was always going to be a hard act to follow just like HM The Queen. I think that this thread would have been no different no matter who the presenter was

 

[iandsm]

I was told the receptionist is an actor not staff

Then she needs acting lessons

 

[Barclaybasher]

The programme and stories are about the DOGS..................

 

[jockaneezer]

Is that who she is, I thought it was Aynsley Harriet in drag !

 

[Dart]

Hands up! I didn't watch the show because I had a gut feeling that it wouldn't be the same without Paul. Problem is that Battersea needs the attention of the public and donations. I am not qualified to put forward suggestions for another presenter but I hope they can eventually settle for someone of Paul's merit.

I didn't see the show either but the person I think would make a good presenter is Martin Clunes. He is another absolute dog lover and animal lover in general.

^{_{Subscribers  do not see these advertisements}}