Replacing AGM with lithium

Joined
May 28, 2024
Posts
1,498
Likes collected
6,364
Location
Maspalomas, Spain
Funster No
103,439
MH
Giottiline Toscan 74
Exp
2024
Yes, I know, this has been thrashed more than the Roman slaves. But, as with everything, in time, things change, and rather than resuscitate a 200 year old thread that is probably way out of date, I thought it better to start a new one as I know I am not the only one on these forums who struggles to understand the ins and outs of the electrical system on our vans. I know there are several people here who DO understand this subject, and as such, do not mind passing on their knowledge, which we all thank you for. So enough of the apologies, and I do apologise for the length of this post (please bear with me) here is the dilemma:

In my motorhome I have 2 95ah agm leisure batteries. I have a 235w Vechline solar panel with a Victron MPPT 100/20 48v controller. An NE325 40A dc-dc and an NE287 17A charger in the system. I now want to change the batteries to lithium so I can use my appliances more freely without worrying about running out of 12v power. The appliances I use are: Bergstrom open air air conditioner, rated at 1.200w, an air fryer rated at 1.400w and an expresso coffee maker rated at 1.340 - 1.600w. I normally only stay off grid for 4 days max and usually there is enough sunshine to recuperate the batteries in 3 hours. However, I am going to drive to Northern Ireland from Cádiz in March and I presume there might not be too much sun to achieve this and albeit I will not be using the air conditioning, I still want to be sure to have enough power on stop overs. So what capacity batteries would I need? and will the 235w solar panel be enough?

I sent this to ChatGpt and this is the answer. Do you experts agree with this?

Energy Consumption:

1. Air Fryer

  • Estimated daily usage: ~20 minutes (0.33 hours).
  • Daily consumption:
    1,400W×0.33hours=462Wh.

2. Espresso Coffee Maker

  • Estimated daily usage: ~15 minutes (0.25 hours).
  • Daily consumption:
    1,600W×0.25hours=400Wh.

3. Lighting, Electronics, and General 12V Use

  • Typical daily consumption: ~300Wh.

4. Heating (if needed in March)

  • If you use a small 12V heater or fan for ~2 hours at 100W:
    100W×2hours=200Wh.
Total Daily Consumption (without air conditioner):
462+400+300+200=1,362Wh (rounded to 1.4 kWh).


Battery Sizing:

Lithium batteries can safely discharge ~90% of their capacity.
To sustain 4 days without solar:
1.4kWh/day×4days=5.6kWh.

For lithium battery capacity:
5,600 Wh0.9≈6,200 Wh\frac{5,600 \, \text{Wh}}{0.9} \approx 6,200 \, \text{Wh}0.95,600Wh≈6,200Wh (6.2kWh, or ~520Ah @ 12V).

Recommendation

  • A 6kWh (500Ah @ 12V)lithium battery bank is ideal.
    • This would give you enough buffer for cloudy weather or higher-than-expected usage.

Solar Panel Performance

Your 235W panel can generate ~1.2 kWh/day under good sunlight conditions (assuming 5 effective sun hours). In March, across northern Europe, sun hours drop to ~2-3 hours/day, yielding ~500-700Wh/day.

  • Conclusion: The solar panel alone is insufficient for your daily usage in March. It can supplement charging but will not cover everything.

Alternator Charging

Your NE325 40A DC-DC charger will deliver ~480W (40A × 12V) to the batteries when driving. In 2 hours of driving:
480 W×2 hours=960 Wh480 \, \text{W} \times 2 \, \text{hours} = 960 \, \text{Wh}480W×2hours=960Wh.

  • If you drive every day or every other day, the alternator can recharge a significant portion of your daily consumption.

Final Recommendations

  1. Battery Capacity:
    • Install 500Ah of lithium batteries (e.g., two 12V 250Ah batteries in parallel).
    • Ensure your system includes a lithium-compatible charger and DC-DC converter settings.
  2. Solar Panel:
    • Your current 235W panel is fine for summer or sunny days but may struggle in March. Consider adding a second panel to increase capacity to ~400-500W.
  3. Alternator Charging:
    • Leverage the NE325 for top-ups during driving days. Ensure it’s configured correctly for lithium batteries.
  4. Battery Monitoring:
    • Use a Victron SmartShunt or similar monitor to keep track of battery state-of-charge.
With this setup, you’ll have plenty of power for your appliances, even with less solar in March.

Thank you for your patience guys 'n girls.

 
That's a lot to run with 2 95Ah AGM 🤪How did you cope? Anyway, throw in 2 x 280Ah or 2 x 300Ah as you may have the room in your AC. I have doubts about the lithium profile in the NE charger (I think you could get away with the GEL profile).
The NE booster should be fine.
And I believe your Victron allows solar up to 290W.
 
That's a lot to run with 2 95Ah AGM 🤪How did you cope? Anyway, throw in 2 x 280Ah or 2 x 300Ah as you may have the room in your AC. I have doubts about the lithium profile in the NE charger.
The NE booster should be fine.
And I believe your Victron allows solar up to 290W.
Thanks Nacho (can I call you that), I don't actually have that much room, at least under the seat where the AGMs are now. But I think you are right. Nordelettronica say the charger is good for lithium, but I have yet to find where it is installed in the van to see what adjustments are available. We have managed up to now by over discharging the AGMs, knowing full well that their life is being reduced as we speak.
 
Nacho (can I call you that)
Sure 🙂(y)
under the seat where the AGMs are now
I thought in your van, the batteries would be somewhere else, I have 200 Ah under the passenger seat, but you could easily fit 230 Ah. Maybe someone here has fitted more Ah under the seat, but you're a bit more limited with the available room there:confused:
 
I wouldn't over-think it. Put in the biggest lithium batteries space/budget allow and see how you get on. The DC-DC charger can always fill in any gaps, especially if you are driving every few days.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
Sure 🙂(y)

I thought in your van, the batteries would be somewhere else, I have 200 Ah under the passenger seat, but you could easily fit 230 Ah. Maybe someone here has fitted more Ah under the seat, but you're a bit more limited with the available room there:confused:
No, mine are under the side facing lounge seat behind the passenger cab seat. There is not much more room than what the AGMs take up because of a metal strut that I think is only there for the seat belt mounting which is not legal here in Spain (being side facing). So maybe I could cut it out and that would open up a lot more space for batteries. I need to look into that possibility.
 
I wouldn't over-think it. Put in the biggest lithium batteries space/budget allow and see how you get on. The DC-DC charger can always fill in any gaps, especially if you are driving every few days.
Thanks DBK, that's what I was thinking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DBK
Well that's another option, but 250ah might be too little in England and Ireland in the winter.
If it is then just drop in to a site every 3rd or 4th day to recharge.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
If it is then just drop in to a site every 3rd or 4th day to recharge.
Yes, that is an option. You may be right, I don't want to spend too much putting in 600ah of power if I'm not going to be using it. Thanks for your input.
 
Well that's another option, but 250ah might be too little in England and Ireland in the winter.
how often would you be driving Barrie, I know you said 4 days max but if any less then worth looking at.
Shame to chuck 400 - 600ah at it just for a few days, as when you get back home its defunkt
 
Looks like you are planning to be a fairly higpoemwerhuseso I would fit as much battery and solar power as you can.

A Victron Multiplus would be worth fitting an awesome bit of kit. It combine inveter/charger and mains pass through and has the function of combining mains input with the inverter so on a 5amp EHU it's easy to run 10amp plus loads.

This is my install.
 
I’m thinking of getting one of these in the next few weeks….🤔

 
how often would you be driving Barrie, I know you said 4 days max but if any less then worth looking at.
Shame to chuck 400 - 600ah at it just for a few days, as when you get back home its defunkt
Tombola, you're absolutely right. We normally drive at least every second day. The times we stayed longer were in cities that had more to offer and we considered we wanted to stay to see the ruins or whatever. I'm going to seriously consider this option. Thank you.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
Yes, I have an LPG refillable installation.
And there is your answer to the NI trip Barrie. Forget your household electrical stuff that runs in your van using solar, which no doubt works well in Spain - just heat and cook by gas for that "up north" trip.
You are unlikely to need air conditioning in NI in March too!
Your B2B will be your most useful charger, especially if you are driving quite a lot. I have 280Ah of LifePO4 and a 50 amp B2B and even if I was to get below 50% SOC, it would back to 100% after a 3 hour drive. In fact, we never hook up and usually operate in the 60-100% zone, that includes charging 2 ebikes (our electric hungry luxury)
Have you heard of an "Aeropress" which produces great coffee without any electricity - only needing hot water.
 
I’m thinking of getting one of these in the next few weeks….🤔

This any good, just get it delivered for your return

Link
 
This site contains affiliate links for which MHF may be compensated.
I have 2 x 95 ah AGM leisure batteries in MH.

Four years ago I had the following fitted by Vanbitz:

Victron 2000 Inverter/Charger
B2B 60 ah
Solar Panel 175 watts
Victron MPPT controller
Smart shunt.

We discussed fitting lithium but decided to see how we got on and changeover when needed. We use a coffee machine, hairdryer and charge the electric bikes. Very rarely use hook up.

We travel a lot in UK and Europe and the AGMs are still going and rarely drop below 90%. I must say the B2B is great in the UK.

I am looking forward to fitting a Fogstar one day!

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
I have 2 x 95 ah AGM leisure batteries in MH.

Four years ago I had the following fitted by Vanbitz:

Victron 2000 Inverter/Charger
B2B 60 ah
Solar Panel 175 watts
Victron MPPT controller
Smart shunt.

We discussed fitting lithium but decided to see how we got on and changeover when needed. We use a coffee machine, hairdryer and charge the electric bikes. Very rarely use hook up.

We travel a lot in UK and Europe and the AGMs are still going and rarely drop below 90%. I must say the B2B is great in the UK.

I am looking forward to fitting a Fogstar one day!
I expect if you do a capacity test they will be well down on capacity.
 
Last edited:
We fitted a Fogstar Fogstar 300ah lithium battery 18 months ago and didn't upgrade any thing else for charging. We already had a 120w solar as fitted by Pilote on our 2019 model. We have just had 10 days away in the highlands, we drove a maximum of 80 miles each day, heating was on every evening and morning, our battery capacity never fell below 80%. Lithium was the best upgrade we've done.
 
Having just gone this route in Spain, my 2p's worth would be to have this work done in NI. You will save a bob or two and if you using 'reliable' components should allay any warranty worries.

We too are going to that island in May-July from Murcia, I will be supplementing my 200w on the roof with 200w folding.

If you do have it done in Spain, I had to have a Spanish built (I think they just put 4 cells in a box and market it) Eleksol battery. Given the non-existant Eleksol customer service I don't recommend them.
 
Or go via Oxfordshire and get Offgrid Power Solutions to install it.
 
And there is your answer to the NI trip Barrie. Forget your household electrical stuff that runs in your van using solar, which no doubt works well in Spain - just heat and cook by gas for that "up north" trip.
You are unlikely to need air conditioning in NI in March too!
Your B2B will be your most useful charger, especially if you are driving quite a lot. I have 280Ah of LifePO4 and a 50 amp B2B and even if I was to get below 50% SOC, it would back to 100% after a 3 hour drive. In fact, we never hook up and usually operate in the 60-100% zone, that includes charging 2 ebikes (our electric hungry luxury)
Have you heard of an "Aeropress" which produces great coffee without any electricity - only needing hot water.
Thank you for the input. I need to study all the suggestions offered.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 

Join us or log in to post a reply.

To join in you must be a member of MotorhomeFun

Join MotorhomeFun

Join us, it quick and easy!

Log in

Already a member? Log in here.

Latest journal entries

Back
Top