Best last-ditch physical security mechanism? (1 Viewer)

Affiliate links here may earn MHF compensation
Apr 3, 2024
59
86
Funster No
102,182
MH
Fiat
We've got an alarm, an immobiliser, etc., etc. But of course, with a high-value vehicle, there are those scum out there who can defeat all those measures. So I was thinking of getting a last-ditch additional barrier.

I'm not keen on a wheel lock as I don't trust the scum to spot it - and if they drive off in a hurry with it still in place it'll probably cause loads of damage.

My first thought was a steering lock. But when I put my thief head on, I would take a portable reciprocating saw, cut through the steering wheel and I'm away. It would probably take about 20 seconds to defeat a regular steering lock, depending on whether I had to make one cut or two.

In discussion, a pedal lock was recommended to me as being better than a steering lock. Again, with my thief head on, the best of them seems to be the Milenco that boxes the pedal in - so you can't just cut the pedals off and slide the security lock off. But it looks like I could still put the saw blade behind the box, cut the box off and again, I'm away. Yes, it's a bit awkward pushing on the cut ends of the levers that once had pedals attached but if I was that way inclined, I'm sure it would be driveable far enough to get it away.

The only one that I don't know how I would defeat is the steering lock that fully encloses the entire steering wheel. But they're damn expensive. And big, too.

When I was a student I had a nasty old Escort which I would park in Birmingham. I routed the low-voltage ignition feed through three switches hidden under the dash. You had to get all three in the right position or it wouldn't start. I'm starting to think that something like that is best. Or taking the distributor arm with me!! Not sure what the modern equivalent is!

Any suggestions?
 

funflair

LIFE MEMBER
Dec 11, 2013
20,039
32,951
Guisborough
Funster No
29,351
MH
MORELO palace
Exp
since 2012
Removable steering wheel (y) OK they could take their own but would need to know what fitting ours is and you can't just buy them over the counter.
 
Jan 22, 2013
1,341
73,308
London SE
Funster No
24,385
MH
A class Adria vision I707
Exp
since 1971
Removable steering wheel is a non starter for the majority of modern motorhomes as they incorporate an air bag in the centre,
A visual deterrent is the way to go, stop the toe rags from deciding to break in the first place,
 
Jun 29, 2015
3,680
61,336
Southampton
Funster No
36,999
MH
caravan (for now)
Exp
on and off since 1984
We've got an alarm, an immobiliser, etc., etc. But of course, with a high-value vehicle, there are those scum out there who can defeat all those measures. So I was thinking of getting a last-ditch additional barrier.

I'm not keen on a wheel lock as I don't trust the scum to spot it - and if they drive off in a hurry with it still in place it'll probably cause loads of damage.

My first thought was a steering lock. But when I put my thief head on, I would take a portable reciprocating saw, cut through the steering wheel and I'm away. It would probably take about 20 seconds to defeat a regular steering lock, depending on whether I had to make one cut or two.

In discussion, a pedal lock was recommended to me as being better than a steering lock. Again, with my thief head on, the best of them seems to be the Milenco that boxes the pedal in - so you can't just cut the pedals off and slide the security lock off. But it looks like I could still put the saw blade behind the box, cut the box off and again, I'm away. Yes, it's a bit awkward pushing on the cut ends of the levers that once had pedals attached but if I was that way inclined, I'm sure it would be driveable far enough to get it away.

The only one that I don't know how I would defeat is the steering lock that fully encloses the entire steering wheel. But they're damn expensive. And big, too.

When I was a student I had a nasty old Escort which I would park in Birmingham. I routed the low-voltage ignition feed through three switches hidden under the dash. You had to get all three in the right position or it wouldn't start. I'm starting to think that something like that is best. Or taking the distributor arm with me!! Not sure what the modern equivalent is!

Any suggestions?
I'm having a Ghost immobiliser fitted, with it the engine won't start until you press 4 buttons on the steering wheel in a set order.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
Oct 28, 2022
592
1,219
Funster No
92,132
MH
Rapido
We've got an alarm, an immobiliser, etc., etc. But of course, with a high-value vehicle, there are those scum out there who can defeat all those measures. So I was thinking of getting a last-ditch additional barrier.

I'm not keen on a wheel lock as I don't trust the scum to spot it - and if they drive off in a hurry with it still in place it'll probably cause loads of damage.

My first thought was a steering lock. But when I put my thief head on, I would take a portable reciprocating saw, cut through the steering wheel and I'm away. It would probably take about 20 seconds to defeat a regular steering lock, depending on whether I had to make one cut or two.

In discussion, a pedal lock was recommended to me as being better than a steering lock. Again, with my thief head on, the best of them seems to be the Milenco that boxes the pedal in - so you can't just cut the pedals off and slide the security lock off. But it looks like I could still put the saw blade behind the box, cut the box off and again, I'm away. Yes, it's a bit awkward pushing on the cut ends of the levers that once had pedals attached but if I was that way inclined, I'm sure it would be driveable far enough to get it away.

The only one that I don't know how I would defeat is the steering lock that fully encloses the entire steering wheel. But they're damn expensive. And big, too.

When I was a student I had a nasty old Escort which I would park in Birmingham. I routed the low-voltage ignition feed through three switches hidden under the dash. You had to get all three in the right position or it wouldn't start. I'm starting to think that something like that is best. Or taking the distributor arm with me!! Not sure what the modern equivalent is!

Any suggestions?
£150 for a disklok, surely a small price to pay for a high value MH? Much cheaper than trackers which we all have to have for insurance?

Also, think outside the box? Engine immobilisers? Im not giving away my secrets on a public forum btw…

Security post is worthwhile, i scrounged one from my employer, so only cost me a bit of concrete and a padlock…
 
Feb 12, 2018
849
5,671
South Yorkshire
Funster No
52,385
MH
Adria Coral 600SL
Exp
Since 2017
That seems to lock the gearbox in one gear, but why can it not be driven off. even if slipping the clutch is needed?

Should be fun if left in reverse! :unsure:

Seriously, the best you can do is have visible and audible deterrents which make another nearby MoHo seem to be a much easier target and accept that the long-stop (hopefully never needed) is the insurance cover you bought.
 

funflair

LIFE MEMBER
Dec 11, 2013
20,039
32,951
Guisborough
Funster No
29,351
MH
MORELO palace
Exp
since 2012
Removable steering wheel is a non starter for the majority of modern motorhomes as they incorporate an air bag in the centre,
A visual deterrent is the way to go, stop the toe rags from deciding to break in the first place,
Works on ours😏 A class with modified dash don’t have air bags.
 

jumar

LIFE MEMBER
Nov 6, 2012
4,112
13,271
Spain
Funster No
23,578
MH
Hymer Tramp
Exp
Since 1994
Works on ours😏 A class with modified dash don’t have air bags.
Really Martin...no Airbag...that's a first for me...other that Heavy commercial vehicles...and my motor scooter..

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 

funflair

LIFE MEMBER
Dec 11, 2013
20,039
32,951
Guisborough
Funster No
29,351
MH
MORELO palace
Exp
since 2012
Really Martin...no Airbag...that's a first for me...other that Heavy commercial vehicles...and my motor scooter..
Yes N+B do on the Flair because they don’t alter the steering wheel position but Morelo and Concorde move the dashboard further forward and move the steering column so can’t use airbags.
 
Aug 14, 2016
52
43
Auverne Rhone-Alpes
Funster No
44,582
MH
Ford Transit 1984
Exp
April 2016
We've got an alarm, an immobiliser, etc., etc. But of course, with a high-value vehicle, there are those scum out there who can defeat all those measures. So I was thinking of getting a last-ditch additional barrier.

I'm not keen on a wheel lock as I don't trust the scum to spot it - and if they drive off in a hurry with it still in place it'll probably cause loads of damage.

My first thought was a steering lock. But when I put my thief head on, I would take a portable reciprocating saw, cut through the steering wheel and I'm away. It would probably take about 20 seconds to defeat a regular steering lock, depending on whether I had to make one cut or two.

In discussion, a pedal lock was recommended to me as being better than a steering lock. Again, with my thief head on, the best of them seems to be the Milenco that boxes the pedal in - so you can't just cut the pedals off and slide the security lock off. But it looks like I could still put the saw blade behind the box, cut the box off and again, I'm away. Yes, it's a bit awkward pushing on the cut ends of the levers that once had pedals attached but if I was that way inclined, I'm sure it would be driveable far enough to get it away.

The only one that I don't know how I would defeat is the steering lock that fully encloses the entire steering wheel. But they're damn expensive. And big, too.

When I was a student I had a nasty old Escort which I would park in Birmingham. I routed the low-voltage ignition feed through three switches hidden under the dash. You had to get all three in the right position or it wouldn't start. I'm starting to think that something like that is best. Or taking the distributor arm with me!! Not sure what the modern equivalent is!

Any suggestions?
This won't stop it being stolen but might help it being found. I've bought 5" numbers & letters and stuck the registration number on the roof. It should help the police helicopter find it (yes I know they'll be too busy) but also plod could look up there and I doubt theives would.
 

MisterB

LIFE MEMBER
Feb 25, 2018
6,706
15,437
Essex
Funster No
52,564
MH
Adria 670 SLT
Exp
enough to know i shouldnt touch things i know nothing about ....
Vanbitz immobiliser, but also consider clutch claw as avisual deterrent

from what i understand, no motorhome has ever been stolen with the vanbitz immobiliser, when its actually been on, though there have been a few attempts, all foiled .....

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 
Feb 16, 2020
538
1,601
United Kingdom
Funster No
68,790
MH
Dethleffs Globetrott
Exp
Newbie
We installed and use all of these as and when we feel they are required (which is most of the time)! A non starter, immobiliser, trackers, alarm, disklock, pedal lock & wheel clamp.

Visual deterrents as well as non visual will help, they may only slow them down, but it may give you/someone enough time to discover them and take action.
 
Jun 30, 2022
676
4,155
Funster No
89,603
MH
burstner lyseo 590
Exp
March 2022
This won't stop it being stolen but might help it being found. I've bought 5" numbers & letters and stuck the registration number on the roof. It should help the police helicopter find it (yes I know they'll be too busy) but also plod could look up there and I doubt theives would.
We have done the same 👍🏼
 
Aug 3, 2021
50
44
Funster No
83,178
MH
Hymer I580
We've got an alarm, an immobiliser, etc., etc. But of course, with a high-value vehicle, there are those scum out there who can defeat all those measures. So I was thinking of getting a last-ditch additional barrier.

I'm not keen on a wheel lock as I don't trust the scum to spot it - and if they drive off in a hurry with it still in place it'll probably cause loads of damage.

My first thought was a steering lock. But when I put my thief head on, I would take a portable reciprocating saw, cut through the steering wheel and I'm away. It would probably take about 20 seconds to defeat a regular steering lock, depending on whether I had to make one cut or two.

In discussion, a pedal lock was recommended to me as being better than a steering lock. Again, with my thief head on, the best of them seems to be the Milenco that boxes the pedal in - so you can't just cut the pedals off and slide the security lock off. But it looks like I could still put the saw blade behind the box, cut the box off and again, I'm away. Yes, it's a bit awkward pushing on the cut ends of the levers that once had pedals attached but if I was that way inclined, I'm sure it would be driveable far enough to get it away.

The only one that I don't know how I would defeat is the steering lock that fully encloses the entire steering wheel. But they're damn expensive. And big, too.

When I was a student I had a nasty old Escort which I would park in Birmingham. I routed the low-voltage ignition feed through three switches hidden under the dash. You had to get all three in the right position or it wouldn't start. I'm starting to think that something like that is best. Or taking the distributor arm with me!! Not sure what the modern equivalent is!

Any suggestions?
The new Disklok is supposed to be very difficult to remove, probably the best steering wheel lock as the thief can’t get at the body of the steering wheel to cut the lock off. As you’ve commented it’s impossible to make any vehicle 100% thief proof, but anything that slows a thief down acts as a deterrent.
 
Jul 8, 2020
34
73
Funster No
72,779
MH
Don't yet own one
Exp
Newbie
We've got an alarm, an immobiliser, etc., etc. But of course, with a high-value vehicle, there are those scum out there who can defeat all those measures. So I was thinking of getting a last-ditch additional barrier.

I'm not keen on a wheel lock as I don't trust the scum to spot it - and if they drive off in a hurry with it still in place it'll probably cause loads of damage.

My first thought was a steering lock. But when I put my thief head on, I would take a portable reciprocating saw, cut through the steering wheel and I'm away. It would probably take about 20 seconds to defeat a regular steering lock, depending on whether I had to make one cut or two.

In discussion, a pedal lock was recommended to me as being better than a steering lock. Again, with my thief head on, the best of them seems to be the Milenco that boxes the pedal in - so you can't just cut the pedals off and slide the security lock off. But it looks like I could still put the saw blade behind the box, cut the box off and again, I'm away. Yes, it's a bit awkward pushing on the cut ends of the levers that once had pedals attached but if I was that way inclined, I'm sure it would be driveable far enough to get it away.

The only one that I don't know how I would defeat is the steering lock that fully encloses the entire steering wheel. But they're damn expensive. And big, too.

When I was a student I had a nasty old Escort which I would park in Birmingham. I routed the low-voltage ignition feed through three switches hidden under the dash. You had to get all three in the right position or it wouldn't start. I'm starting to think that something like that is best. Or taking the distributor arm with me!! Not sure what the modern equivalent is!

Any suggestions?
Can't really help you. Talking of old Fords though, the MK1 Fiesta I once had was the best. There was a real knack to starting it & one mistake flooded it. Then it was a good 5 minutes wait before you'd have any chance of another try.
It totally defeated thieves who hot wired it on at least one occasion. Who needs security devices!
 

DBK

LIFE MEMBER
Jan 9, 2013
18,426
49,833
Plympton, Devon
Funster No
24,219
MH
PVC, Murvi Morocco
Exp
2013
This is our deterrent of last resort. Unfortunately, it can be disabled with a biscuit...

PXL_20230913_114546606.jpg
 
Feb 5, 2024
177
323
Funster No
101,061
MH
Etrusco CV540 DB
I have deadlocks all round, a Rewire tracker, a bar type steering lock, motorcycle disc locks to lock the seats in a position whereby the backs block the side windows, and a modification which disables the auto gearbox. If I told you how I did that I would have to kill you so it will remain my secret. It means they might start the engine but they ain't going anywhere!
 
May 7, 2017
2,092
2,452
Suffolk
Funster No
48,544
MH
Chausson 788
Exp
20 years
As said before thickish high tensile chain around suspension leg through wheel locked with heavy £80 high tensile pad lock, ( using portable hand grinder I can assure you you would need a few discs to cut it off) hopefully somebody / neighbours would here noise if we are out . Would they nock a Transit knowing the cambelt in oil problems,and injector problems ?😂
 
May 24, 2022
54
86
Funster No
88,865
MH
Converted VW Crafter
You say you have a immobiliser but we have an S5 plus tracker too. This means that even if the van is picked up e.g. tilted to put on a trailer without starting it, it will notify a call center who will ring us and then the police if need be.

Subscribers  do not see these advertisements

 

Join us or log in to post a reply.

To join in you must be a member of MotorhomeFun

Join MotorhomeFun

Join us, it quick and easy!

Log in

Already a member? Log in here.

Latest journal entries

Funsters who are viewing this thread

Back
Top